Personal Halfquake
StartGeneral InformationCreate Institute
View AllSearchView Statistics

Review by TheNameless, February 13th 2007, 15:04:56
Who watches the Watchmen?
The Comedian is dead. And so is the world of the real superheroes.
That is the Situation at the beginning of the comic "Watchmen"
by Alan Moore (writer) and Dave Gibbons (illustrator/letterer).
Many people refer to this piece of artwork as more than a comic:
A graphic novel. These are some sort of illustrated stories which try not to
be just thoughtless entertainment. It won many awards since its publication 1986/87 including the famous Hugo award and is part of Time Magazine's list of the 100 best novels.
It imagines a world in which the superheroes became real. But not like
Superman. Alan Moore places Normal people in costumes and puts them
in the deep and dark world of the cold war.

The Story
Edward Blake was killed. Thrown out of the window of his apartment in a skyscraper in downtown New York. No Clues.
He was formerly known as The Comedian, a masked vigilante
who used to fight crime in the streets. It is now the mid-eighties and since the Keen Act, crimefighting in costumes is against the law and most superheroes retired. Some of them wrote their autobiography, some are working for the government and some get killed.
And one of them is still active. His name is Rorschach and most people
regard him as completely insane. He investigates the recent killings of former masked adventurers. He talks to retired villains and old friends but the case just doesn't seem to make sense. Meanwhile Russia invades Pakistan and tanks gather in east germany. Will the president consider a first strike on the enemy? The whole world is on the edge of nuclear doom. The story takes place under the dark preapocalyptik mood before a third world war.
The heroes who started acting in the late thirties were outlawed in their second generation in 1977. They are just as powerless, as the rest.
The uncertainty principle lives.
Schroedinger's Humankind: Is it dead or alive?

Narrating Technique
The story isn't verly linear. There is no real main character.
It's told from the point of view of various persons and has a busload full of
subplots. They seem to be independent, describing the world the story
takes place in, but in the end they are all connected. The reader realizes that
at the end of the story, so somehow with all the little but important hints
you overlooked at the first perusal, you almost get forced to read it again.
The second time you're gonna be even more impressed reading it.
Watchmen is devided into 12 Chapters, each ending with 3 to 4 pages of texts from this world. For example an excerpt from the autobio of one of
the first masked vigilantes, describing why he became one. Or newspaperarticles from the New Frontiersman, a rightwing paper.
The sources couldn't be more different. All written in their own authentic style, just like each and every individual charakter has its own way of speaking. The texts create a whole lot of atmosphere, interrupt the comic reading a bit, though.
The style in general is abolutely excellent, the language is really sophisticated.
If you are not a native english-speaker, the dictionary should
lie right next to Watchmen.

The Art
Drawn by Dave Gibbons and colored by John Higgins. Since it was drawn
in the eighties and is a superhero story it has the really classical style of
e.g. superman comics. It is of course a bit more detailed and has much more
blood than the comics of the most famous crimefighter, but I think it is comparable. There are often really creative changeovers from scene to scene and the art is just as important for telling the story as the text.
You can have a look at the art in the uploaded pictures. Also there's a link,
where all pages of the comic can be seen. I found this site via Google and
I don't know whether this is ok with copyright law, but... it's good to get
an impression of the drawing style.

A story is just as good as its writer
Who is Alan Moore? He was born 1953 in Northampton, central England, and still resides there. Born under rather poor circumstances and influenced by
many comics, especially Superman, he was expelled from school and
managed to get small jobs as a cartoonist, but later as a writer for
small series and became famous doing it. His most famous works are:
V for Vendetta, Swamp Thing, Marvelman (also Miracleman), The League Of
Extraordinary Gentleman, From Hell
and quite some more. He was and still is
one of the leading innovators of the comic genre and was the first one to
bring topics to comics which were not at present in the medium at all.
He is often referred to as the father of the graphic novel, but he himself just calles his genre comic. He is also a big critic of the mainstream comics.
Many awards have been given to his works which are very often of an
experimental nature.

Personal impressions
Watchmen is much like a parody of all the superhero stories, not
in a funny but a tragic way. It really gets you to think about certain
issues pretty hard, it forces you to do that. The story is digging into the
deepest abyss of human morality and leaves you to give an answer.
The connection of all the story parts and the creation of the whole world
and its atmosphere is simply incredible. It is one of the most
sophisticated and impressive pieces of art I have come across to this day.
Even if you are not into comics or superheroes, this is highly recommendable.
Though you will have to pay to buy and read it, you will be richer afterwards.
Cover of Watchmen 1/12

Picture of Watchmen Characters

Example Site of the first chapter

Another Watchmen cover (showing Dr.Manhattan)

Alan Moore and his rough appearance

>Watching the Detectives: An Internet Companion for Readers of Watchmen
>Dennette's Watchmen Page
>Tales Of The Black Frighter: Marooned (The Reconstruction) (one of the subplots)
>Comlete Watchmen comic online (found via google)
>Watchmen for purchase on
How readers rate this Review: 9.66/10 (3 votes)
Other Reviews:
>Halfquake Sunrise
>Them Crooked Vultures - Album Review
>Bon Iver - Blood Bank EP
>Mando Diao - Give Me Fire
>Black Ice by AC/DC
>Elect the Dead by Serj Tankian
>Half-Life 2: Episode 2
>Knights of the old Republic
>Neverwinter Nights 1
>Open Transport Tycoon Deluxe
Latest additions:
>Laurie Cheers - Programmer, Creator of Spirit of Half-Life
>Mike Hillard - Voice Actor, Musician, Artist, Evil Scientist
>PHQ Interview with Muddasheep
>Halfquake Sunrise
>Them Crooked Vultures - Album Review
>Tailsteak - Cartoonist and Writer
>Moving Mountains with Motivation
>Bon Iver - Blood Bank EP
>Experiment with a Gate
>Mando Diao - Give Me Fire
If you want to add your comment you must login or register first.

View AllSearchView Statistics

More StatisticsRankingsPersonal PagesArticles
Copyright Muddasheep 2003-2099